Monday, 26 June 2017

Physical Separation '17 conference diary

The Physical Separation conferences, of which Physical Separation '17 was the 5th in the series, are among MEI's smaller conferences, but always attract interesting practical people. This year's event, held from June 15-16 at the St. Michael's Hotel, Falmouth, Cornwall was the biggest in the series, in no small part due to the attraction of two eminent well known keynote speakers, and strong corporate support.
Physical Separation '17 sponsors

Thursday June 15th
I opened the conference this morning, welcoming the 71 delegates from 12 countries to this beautiful part of the world. I then had the pleasant duty of presenting Swadhin Saurabh, of Millcreek Engineering Company, USA, with the 2016 MEI Young Person's Award (posting of 15th June).
Sandy Gray, Managing Director of Gekko Systems, Australia, was a finalist this year for the Austmine Champion of Innovation Award. He also received the AusIMM 2017 Professional Excellence Award, and in Denver in February was inducted into International Mining Technology's Hall of Fame. So we were honoured to have Sandy present the first keynote lecture at the conference.
As he pointed out, physical separation features in almost every mineral processing circuit. The category encompasses a broad range of techniques and technologies including hydrocyclones, gravity concentration methods (including jigs, spirals, centrifugal concentrators, tables and heavy media separators), and thickeners, all of which make use of the inherent density difference between two mediums. We can also include amongst numerous other technologies, flotation, magnetic separation, and ore sorting in the physical separation category.
However, opportunities for enhanced physical separation performance can now go beyond the common practice of optimising unit operation. Improved options exist for feed preparation ahead of the physical separation stage, enabling higher performance and lower cost outcomes for physical separation flowsheets and technologies.
The use of new applications in breakage technologies combined with mineral liberation analysis to optimise liberation prior to the physical separation stage provide options for pre-concentration, gangue rejection as well as better separation efficiency. The use of low cost gangue rejection and pre-concentration can be an intermediate step between mining and processing that allows lower cut-off grades in the mine whilst delivering higher grades to the mill. Optimising flowsheets and technology performance requires detailed exploration of particle size, shape as well as liberation to suit the particular separation unit combined with a strong knowledge of the available technologies, their capabilities and economic impact across the whole mining system and lifecycle (more info
Sandy Gray (centre) with Bill Weldon and Simon Hille
Tumbling mills, both AG/SAG and Ball are now well accepted to be energy and process inefficient. Rob Morrison, of CRC Ore, Australia, reviewed the development of a new generation of comminution devices which can produce much steeper product size distributions. Combined with precise classification, these devices will produce feeds which are well suited to gravity concentration and should reduce flotation losses at both coarse and fine sizes. They would also potentially be tailored to precision liberation of gangue phases and thus provide a new option to facilitate up front rejection opportunities in the mine ahead of processing (more info
Rob Morrison with Viv Delaney
The efficiency improvement in the comminution of ores has been on the international agenda of the innovative mining industry for some time but substantial advances are still relatively scarce. It is generally agreed that major goals include a substantially reduced energy consumption, systems that operate dry, markedly enhanced particle size reduction, and improved particle liberation. New systems that have been introduced to the market utilise the differential properties of the components within heterogeneous materials such as sulphide ore minerals in silicate or carbonate gangue. These systems use either electrical or mechanical stimulation to create drastically increased stress along particle boundaries that result in breakage, size reduction and thus in the liberation of the commodity minerals. Gregor Borg, of PMS GmbH & Martin Luther University Halle-Wittenberg, Germany, discussed developments in the VeRo Liberator®, which was invented some four years ago and applies a completely new, mechanical comminution principle, which is high-velocity and high-frequency impact comminution. This improved breakage behaviour results in a drastically reduced energy consumption of between 3 and 13 kWh/t, very high degrees of particle liberation, and particle size reduction ratios of up to 6.250 in single pass comminution. Positive side effects of the technique are the embrittlement of ductile (metal) particles, very low noise levels, and a drying effect for moist or wet feed material, allowing for subsequent dry sieving. Gregor claimed that the VeRo Liberator® can either replace several conventional comminution steps or can reduce the application of less (energy) efficient technique to a minimum (more info
Gregor Borg (left) with Christoph Priess
Kai Bartram
There was much more on sorting, now an increasingly important technique, in the five papers following the coffee break. Sensor-based automatic ore sorting technologies can be used in the minerals industries to efficiently remove excessive waste and sub-marginal grade material from pre-mined low grade stockpiles, producing a coarse (typically >10mm) upgraded potential plant feed. If upgrading is successful, a supplementary high-margin ore feed can be generated from such stockpiles with minimal capital investment and no requirement for increased mining activity, thereby contributing to increased economic returns to the operations. Kai Bartram, of Steinert, Germany) reviewed the bulk ore sorting testwork undertaken on material from low grade open pit stockpiles at Volcan Compania Minera SAA’s base metals operations in Peru and provided an economic analysis of the potential benefits of ore sorting based on the testwork results and likely operating parameters for a commercial plant (more info

Jens-Michael Bergmann
German companies TOMRA and Steinert are the world leaders in the manufacture of electronic sorting machines, and in the next paper, Jens-Michael Bergmann introduced TOMRA´s latest multi-channel laser sorting machine, which opens new opportunities for mining companies. Minerals which could not be differentiated with existing technologies, for instance colour, X-ray transmission, X-ray Fluorescence, Near Infrared or Electromagnetic sensors, can now be identified and separated. The patented new sorter technology uses the scattering effect of multiple lasers inside a detector unit (more info
Preconcentration consists of the previous discarding of a fraction of the mineral processing plant feed with little or none of the mineral of interest, reducing the mass to be processed in downstream operations (e.g. milling, concentration and dewatering), as well as the capital and operational costs. In this context, Dimas Neto, of the University of São Paulo, Brazil, described an investigation into the performance of density and sensor separation techniques in the removal of the carbonatic gangue of a Brazilian zinc ore, in fraction sizes typical of crusher product, using sink and float tests with heavy liquid, jig stratification and ore sorting with an XRT sensor laboratory scale tests. The best results were in the sink and float in heavy liquid, which indicate the possibility of discarding 30% of the feed mass of the plant, removing over 50% of carbonate, while losing only 2% of the zinc. The ore sorting tests also presented positive results, with an average of 93% metallurgical recovery in 73% of the mass. The results indicate the significant reduction potential of Capex and Opex using preconcentration (more info
Dimas Neto with Mauricio Bergerman and Kai Bartram
Jacek Kolacz, of COMEX AS, Norway, reviewed modern sensor-based sorting techniques, focusing on X-ray sorting. He described the construction of the X-ray separator CXR series (Comex X-ray sorting) produced by Comex AS, which uses XRT technology (X-Ray Transmission). There is a thesis that the sorting process using the XRT technology may be an alternative for pre-concentration of Zn-Pb ore, which is usually perfomed by heavy media separation (more info
Sensor-based sorting technology has in fact been around since the 1930s, mainly for high value minerals and metals, food preparation and recycled scrap. It is the recent developments in sensor detectors, together with the higher capacity of the machines, that have made extending the application to the mining industry possible. Jacek Kolacz also presented the results of pilot plant tests carried out on samples of Brazilian iron ore using an x-ray transmission sensor with high selectivity, aimed at the removal of low density particles, and increasing the iron content on the final products, and the early removal of tailings before of run-of-mine milling (more info
Jacek Kolacz and Lewis Baker
Jacques Eksteen of Curtin University, Australia, discussed an assessment of the amenability of gold ores to coarse particle gangue rejection in the pumpable range, characterising and evaluating liberation and separation of gangue from gold-bearing middlings and liberated gold and gold-bearing sulfide particles in the -5 mm size range in general, and more specifically in the -2 mm +0.3 mm size range (as typically generated post tertiary crushing). Liberation patterns produced by various crushing modes (Vertical Shaft Impact (VSI) crushing, Cone crushing, SelFrag® and High Pressure Grinding Roll crushing) were investigated to assess the possibility of preferential and ideal liberation from a particular crusher type for a given ore (more info
Jacques Eksteen (centre) with Rob Morrison and Tim Napier-Munn
Steve Walters, of CRC Ore, Australia, described a pilot study demonstrating the physical separation benefits of ROM material through the application of screening. He detailed a pilot trial program comprising three 200kt production blasts. 80kt of ROM material was fed through a mobile screening plant over a three-month period to quantify the physical separation achievable through blasting and screening strategies. The results indicated that 63% more copper could be produced from creating two ROM streams that were processed differently (i.e. dump leach and concentrator). This result was integrated into a system value financial assessment to define the economic potential achievable through coarse separation via screening (more info
Steve Walters (left) with Daniel Amariei and Richard Shaw
Steve Walters was back on the podium after lunch, to introduce Grade Engineering®, an integrated methodology for deploying a range of coarse separation technologies and operational scenarios in hard rock mining operations to deliver value through early gangue rejection and pay element pre-concentration. Within Grade Engineering® five technology ‘levers’ are recognized that drive coarse separation outcomes (>10mm) - natural preferential grade by size deportment, differential blasting for grade; sensor based bulk sorting; sensor based stream sorting; and coarse gravity separation. In order to assess relative techno-economic merits based on applying individual levers or sets of levers for specific ores and operations, it is necessary to define comparative response attributes through a process of physical testing and simulation, much of this work representing ongoing development supported by a consortium of over 30 Miners, Mining Equipment and Technology Suppliers and research providers (more info
With depleting iron reserves and difficult market conditions, precision in separation efficiency is of utmost importance for all separation related equipment in processing plants. Classical local control options are predominant in the industry, but their inability to quickly adjust to varying operational inputs has necessitated the need of developing and implementing continuous control methodologies. High gradient magnetic separation (HGMS) is an important technique in iron ore processing and Riddhika Jain, of Ouotec Inc., USA, highlighted the recent automation development for the Outotec SLon VPHGMS, showing how these modern control options result in improved separation efficiencies, promote safer operations and reduce operational expenses from maintenance and manpower (more info
Riddhika Jain with Pablo Brito-Parada
HGMS is a key method in the concentration of ilmenite ores, and Luzheng Chen, of Kunming University of Science and Technology, China, discussed the processing of ilmenite tailings from Panzhihua ilmenite reserve in Chinese Sichuan province; this reserve accounts for more than 90% of the titanium resource of China and over 35% of the world. Until recently, however, the recovery has been just slightly over 20% with the pulsating HGMS-flotation technology which is widely applied in China. In recent years HGMS in a centrifugal field has been investigated, which produces a high selectivity for ilmenite and significantly improves the TiO2 grade fed to cleaning by flotation, and benefits to the enhanced separation of ilmenite from the tailings (more info
Luzheng Chen (2nd right) with other delegates from China: Jie Wang, Hong Li, Ku Jiangang, Xiong Dahe and Jin Wei Chen
A new approach in modelling the magnetic separation of Ta and W ores, conducted on a laboratory wet high intensity magnetic separator (WHIMS), was described by Filipp Zolotarev, of the Institute of Mineral Processing Machines, Germany. Using a fundamental approach based on mineral composition and susceptibility measurements of a gravity concentrate from a European Ta deposit, the influence of particle size, field intensity, solid content and other parameters on recovery and separation quality were investigated. The aim of the work is to implement recognized dependencies of recovery and separation quality on the parameters determined in experimental tests in a simulation model. The empirical model was presented and compared with models commonly used in the industry, conclusions being drawn for more efficient operation of WHIMS in industrial applications with real-time process control (more info
Electrostatic separation is an important preconcentration technique utilized in the beneficiation of monazite. As part of a feasibility study being undertaken at the University of South Australia to separate rare earth element minerals from selected low grade ores found in South Australia, George Abaka-Wood described an extensive laboratory investigation carried out on model mixtures. Most of the rare earth elements deposits in South Australia are associated with hematite and quartz minerals, hence mixtures of monazite, hematite, and, quartz were used. The purpose of the investigation was to determine the optimum separation conditions for concentrating monazite from model mixtures using electrostatic separation. The influence of electric field intensity, radial distance, and particle size distribution on separation efficiency were investigated. The results obtained are consistent with the electrical properties of the minerals used, showing that preconcentration by means of electrostatic separation is feasible for attaining significant monazite upgrade, with selectivity being particle size dependent (more info 
Lewis Baker, of ST Equipment & Technology LLC, USA, showed how the STET tribo-electrostatic belt separator provides the mineral processing industry with a means to beneficiate fine materials with an entirely dry technology. The triboelectric belt separator technology has been used to separate a wide range of materials including calcite/quartz, talc/magnesite, carbon/silicates and barite/quartz. Lewis claimed that the enhanced separation capabilities of the STET system may be a very effective alternative to flotation processes. An economic comparison conducted by an independent mineral processing consulting firm of the tribo-electrostatic belt separator versus conventional flotation for barite / quartz separation illustrates the advantages of dry processing for minerals, with significantly lower capital and operating expenses, and a greatly simplified process flow sheet. Following successful commissioning of an STET barite processing facility in India, performance data was presented to illustrate the effectiveness of STET’s technology implementation (more info 

The weather in Falmouth has been glorious all week, and shortly after final coffee, I took most of the delegates on our usual 3 and a half mile coastal path walk into old Falmouth, for welcome drinks by the inner harbour at the award-winning real ale pub, The 'Front, kindly sponsored by Grinding Solutions Ltd (see also posting of 15th June).
On Pendennis Headland

By the docks
Drinks by the inner harbour
Friday June 16th
Physical Separation ’17 is a direct descendent of the 1st Gravity Concentration Conference, which was held at the Camborne School of Mines in 1990. The keynote speaker at that conference was Tim Napier-Munn, of the JKMRC, Australia, who gave a progress report on the modelling and simulation of dense medium separation processes (Minerals Engineering Volume 4 nos. 3-4, 1991). Tim became Director of the JKMRC in 1997, and, now semi-retired, it was great to have him back in Cornwall to present the 2nd keynote lecture of the conference, appropriately on the past, present and future of the dense medium cyclone (DMC).
Since the dense medium cyclone was first patented in the 1940s it has become the process of choice in coal preparation, and is also widely used for upgrading iron ore and in the pre-concentration of diamonds and metalliferous and industrial minerals. It is in every sense a mature technology. Tim summarised the history of the process, and considered its current status in mineral and coal processing, suggesting ways in which the process might evolve. Particular attention was given to the potential for the use of larger cyclones at lower heads in mineral separations, as practiced in the coal industry. Using operating data and simulation models, he suggested that these conditions will work in minerals too, and should be adopted, as this will significantly improve the economics of DMC mineral separations at a time when pre-concentration is becoming more important for upgrading lower grade ores (more info
Density tracers are often used to identify the separation efficiency of the mineral processing equipment and overall plant performance in several mineral and coal applications. Damla Izerdem, of Hacettepe University, Turkey, described a plant audit in a 700 tph Turkish coal washing plant, comprising dense medium drums and dense medium cyclones, using density tracers. Besides the detailed separation behavior of the particles in drums and cyclones, some variables affecting the performance such as particle retention, cut-point and separation efficiency were also discussed (more info
Turkish delegates Ozgur Ozkan, Damla Izerdem and Mehmet Akgun
David Powell, of Mintek, South Africa, described a pilot test campaign to evaluate DMS cyclone separation efficiencies on samples of iron ore fines (-1mm +300µm) using both gas and water atomised FeSi types across a range of operating conditions in the presence of slimes build-up. A Mineral Liberation Analyser (MLA) was used to measure size, density, shape and liberation data of DMS feed and products. The results of the test work were used to obtain parameters for modelling of the partition size/density response. The findings indicated that accurate density characterisation of the feed ore is essential in understanding product quality and recovery, particularly due to the effect of porosity and micro-inclusions. The presence of slimes and control of rheology in the FeSi media was demonstrated to be essential in obtaining efficient separation (more info
David Powell (right), with Jong-Leng Liow, Patrick Hegarty and Dave Goldburn
Taking us to the coffee break, Jong-Leng Liow, of the University of New South Wales, Australia, discussed the performance of mini-axial hydrocyclones, which have been much less studied than the reversed flow hydrocyclones but can be a viable alternative by providing lower pressure drop losses for the same Reynolds number (more info
Following the break, Dennis Vega, of Imperial College, UK, discussed the optimisation of small hydrocyclones for fine particle classification. The processing of fine (minus 20 µm) ore presents many challenges. Small diameter (10 mm) hydrocyclones have been applied successfully for particle classification in the micro size range due to the fact that their diameter is in direct relation to the particle cutsize that can be achieved. The design of these units, however, has not been fully explored. Testwork has shown that the dimensions of small hydrocyclone units (spigot diameter, vortex finder diameter) can be effectively manipulated to enhance separation performance, the results providing a more complete understanding of design effects in small hydrocyclones than achieved to date (more info
Dennis Vega with Pablo Brito-Parada and Hylke Glass
Ozgur Ozcan, of Hacettepe University, Turkey, compared classification techniques such as hydrocyclones and the teetered bed separator for their size separation performance. The results of plant and laboratory studies were then used to improve the performance of a conventional closed circuit grinding plant, producing the raw material required for the production of Autoclave aerated concrete in Turkey (more info
In order to investigate the impact of density on the classification behaviour of particles in the static classifier in a Vertical Spindle Mill, Hong Li, of China University of Mining & Technology, showed how narrowly sized pyrite, carborundum, quartz and coal samples were classified at different air flow rates by a lab-scale classifier. Size-by-size efficiency comparison demonstrated that particles with higher density have lower classification efficiency at a certain air flow rate, and based on the Whiten’s model, a new classification efficiency model with the addition of particle density in various forms was established to reevaluate the efficiency of materials with different density in the identical experiment conditions (more info
At present accurate determination of fine screen performance is best done by means of conducting full scale screening tests with representative sample material. By its nature, full scale test work can be quite resource intensive. Elizma Ford, of Mintek, South Africa, presented a test work approach that can efficiently provide a suitable number of experimental data points to model the partition function of a given screen over a wide range of feed conditions. She showed how this approach can offer benefits to metallurgists involved with screening circuit design and operation of industrial screening circuits (more info
The IHC jig was developed to process feed from alluvial deposits to recover gold or tin. Extensive tests have been conducted in the past and these have led to the current knowledge base of the IHC jig. When the material fed to the jig changes drastically, this knowledge is challenged. As the circular economy is strongly promoted by governments, more man-made materials must be treated in order to recover valuable materials and metals for re-use, this driving the need for efficient and clean separation methods. In the recycling industry gravity separation is often considered, as it does involve materials with different densities and does not require chemical additives. Gravity separation has to be adapted to these new materials, as material characteristics differ and their influence on the separation process in the jig sets new challenges to the equipment design. Taco de Boer, of IHC Mining, The Netherlands, discussed design requirements and the steps undertaken to adapt the IHC jig accordingly (more info .
Taco de Boer with Amanda Wills
Martin Brandauer, of Karlsruhe Institute of Technology, Germany, was first on after lunch to discuss the treatment of radioactive waste from abrasive water jet cutting. The cutting of activated components in the decommissioning of nuclear facilities with abrasive water jet cutting results in a mixture of abrasive particles and radioactive steel chips. With the help of a magnet rod filter, treatment of this waste is being pursued in order to allow the treatment of the used abrasive constituting the major part of the mixture (more info
The Nechalacho deposit, located in the Northwest Territories, Canada, is a heavy rare earth element (REE) deposit. Of the various REE-bearing minerals in the deposit, zircon is of significant importance, due to its elevated heavy rare earth element (HREE) content. Most studies performed on this ore to date have focused on fully liberating REE-bearing minerals through fine grinding (-53 micron) prior to a separation stage, however, previous lab scale work has shown that zircon is concentrated in relatively coarse sizes following shorter grinds. The current work, described by Chris Marion, of McGill University, Canada, investigated the pre-concentration of zircon by selective comminution followed by a gravity separation stage of the enriched coarse feed. From the grind study, it was determined that the optimum particle size distribution for upgrading zircon in coarse fractions occurred at 80 % passing 106 micron, with significant upgrading observed in the +53 micron fraction. This fraction was subsequently processed by dense media separation, a spiral and a Knelson Concentrator to determine if further upgrading can be achieved (more info
Monazite which is a phosphate mineral commonly containing rare earth elements (typically lanthanum, cerium, and neodymium), occurs in association with hematite and quartz gangue minerals in some South Australian ores. In an investigation carried out at the University of South Australia, descibed by George Abaka-Wood, the feasibility of exploiting the differences in specific gravity to concentrate monazite from hematite and quartz minerals mixture was studied. A Knelson concentrator was used to determine the influence of feed mass (50 – 300 g), operating water pressure (1.5 – 4.5 psi) and bowl rotation speed (40 – 70 Hz) on beneficiation of monazite from model mineral mixtures. The findings demonstrate that multi-gravity separation may be used to concentrate monazite mineral from low grade lateritic ores where complete liberation of constituent minerals have been achieved. The concentrate generated may further be purified to enhance monazite upgrade via magnetic separation or froth flotation (more info
Rob Fitzpatrick, of Camborne School of Mines, UK, used a Mozley Multi-Gravity Separator (MGS) to promote recovery of fine tungsten-bearing minerals from a waste stream from a European tungsten mine. The mine produces a magnetic waste stream from a low-intensity magnetic separator which has been found to contain approximately 20%WO3. Quantitative mineralogical analyses of this stream have shown that the tungsten is mostly contained within ferberite (FeWO4) which is well liberated from hematite, the main gangue mineral in the magnetic stream. The ferberite exhibits varying degrees of weathering and alteration. Further analysis using an electron microprobe has shown that the weathering is associated with a decrease in the tungsten content in the mineral structure resulting in a range of Fe:W ratios. Mineralogical analysis suggested that it should be possible to recover liberated, unweathered (tungsten rich) ferberite from this waste stream by using the MGS to exploit the difference in density. Under optimal conditions it was predicted that 40% of the tungsten could be recovered above the required grade of 43%WO3 (more info
McGill University's Chris Marion was back on the podium for the final presentation of the conference. He discussed the challenges faced as mineral deposits become increasingly more finely disseminated. Fine grinding, required for liberation, creates many challenges when trying to treat these ores, and many separation techniques become ineffective. Gravity separation techniques traditionally require relatively coarse material to effectively concentrate valuables, however, the development of centrifugal gravity separators, such as the Knelson Concentrator, has allowed for the processing of much finer material. While the Knelson Concentrator is well established for treating gold ores, due to its relatively low cost and small environmental impact when compared to other separation techniques, it has become an active area of research for the processing of low-density deposits. Chris described an investigation to determine the optimum operating conditions when processing fine (-38 micron) low-density material using a laboratory 3-in Knelson Concentrator (more info
MEI's Amanda Wills closed the conference, inviting everyone to attend Physical Separation '19, which will be held in Cape Town in April 2019. 
Final cream tea in the hotel gardens
Then after a final cream tea in the hotel gardens, I gave a brief introduction to Cornwall's copper and tin mining heritage, after which we travelled the 12 miles to the heart of the historic Camborne-Redruth area, for a leisurely 2 mile stroll around the now severely overgrown ruins of the 19th and early 20th century Basset mines, which finally closed in 1918 (see also posting of 16th June).

Draft papers presented at the conference are available from MEI Online.

Twitter @barrywills


  1. Dear Barry, just wanted to say how much I enjoyed the Physical Separation Conference.
    Many thanks to you, Amanda and Jon, it was a good conference.
    Best regards
    Vivien Delaney, Technical Proposals Engineer, Salter Cyclones, UK

  2. Dr. Wills,

    I must say that I gained a lot of information in Physical Separation 2017 conference on the latest physical separation technologies being pursued worldwide. I felt that it was a very high quality specialty conference by including many of the world's top research and industry leaders.


    Swadhin Saurabh

  3. I am very much delighted to note that so much high level work involving mineral engineers from all over the world is being done. My sincere felicitations to all concerned.
    Arun Dongrey, M/S Dongrey & Associates, India

  4. Barry, congrats to you and the team for maintaining high end quality metallurgical conferences and publications. It's appreciated!
    Elizabeth Lewis-Gray, Gekko Systems, Australia

  5. I would like to thank you very much for the successful Physical Separation conference in Falmouth. It was an honor to meet you. Sadly, I couldn’t have a chance to thank you in person. It was a wonderful experience and a great opportunity for me to meet many people who are very well known in their own professions.

    I also would like to thank Jon and Amanda for their help and their hospitality.

    Best regards, Damla
    Damla İzerdem, Research Assistant, Hacettepe University, Turkey

  6. Great to see this separation conference in Falmouth. Would have loved to have been able to make it. Great to see this industry coming together for a conference, would love to see more of these in the future.


If you have difficulty posting a comment, please email the comment to and I will submit on your behalf